This report and analysis was generated on a iteration in the middle of the design phase. Hence the reference to previous versions of the game at points in the text.
This set of experiments implements the rules as defined after the playtest sessions up to 3rd May 2023. This includes the changes:
The previous issue with players having no need to hire smugglers has been resolved. Smugglers are now hired (and betrayed). However the game-end triggers are now vastly different - games almost always end due to the Corruption track or deck exhaustion. This may suggest that the tracks (and/or deck sizes) need to be adjusted to obtain the desired balance of end-game conditions.
Only one set of agents is reported here, with 5 seconds of thinking time per decision given that this has been found to be equivalent to good human play in previous iterations. Except where otherwise stated, the results are the average over 100 games.
Games were run with each of 2, 3 and 4 players.
Plotting the number of rounds that games last, it is just about possible for a 4-player game to finish in Round 4; but on average 3/4-player games last for 8 rounds, and 2-player games for 10 rounds.
An early finish occurs when Thugs appear early in the Smuggler deck, and a player in second place uses these to accelerate the game given the new rule that if the game ends due to Corruption, then the `winner’ actually gets zero points. The rule change certainly has an effect on the way the game is played.
With the new rule changes, games end either because of deck exhaustion; or because of the corruption track. The Ammonia and Contraband victory conditions that were previously dominant now trigger very rarely (and even more so once you move beyond 2 players). A tentative conclusion is that the Corruption track needs to be extended; or the Ammonia/Contraband tracks shortened. (Finding an optimum ratio of track lengths given a specific target of how often the game should end one way or the other is possible using the framework.)
This supports observations in human play-testing that the Corruption track rapidly gets to the end, and good players need to manage it down by betraying smugglers. The previous behavior observed of jockeying for rank position to sell Ammonia and Contraband immediately after other players to maximise the medal score is now less obvious. Instead players try to accelerate the Corruption track to the end if they are second; or try to be first when one of the moon decks is exhausted.
This is reinforced by the next set of graphs show the position of the Ammonia, Contraband and Corruption tracks at game-end. The faint vertical lines show the terminal track positions of each (25, 36 and 16 respectively).
It is immediately clear that the Corruption end-track is regularly hit, with Ammonia and Contraband tracks often not budging from zero, especially beyond 2 players.
The next graph shows the scores of players according to their ordinal position.
Note the peak at zero due to the frequency of the Corruption game-end trigger. There remains a very wide spread in scores; with zero now very common given the rules that trigger if the game ends due to corruption.
This table summarises how many medals have been acquired by game end.
Due to the game ending prematurely (compared to previous runs), the higher-level medals are very rarely seen. Whereas previously the value 5 medals were regularly acquired, now this never happens beyond 2-players, and is very rare even then.
The following graphs shows how cards are distributed between their different locations in 5 sample games for each player count. Thiis is more informative than just looking at the average, as each game can be very different in the details.
There is one graph per card type (Ammonia, Contraband, Smugglers, Favours). In each case cards may be:
Note that Smuggler Cards are now picked up avidly and do not get left on the Moon. However Favour cards are not very active; note the sample games with 2-players in which it is possible that no player thinks it worthwhile to go the Favour moon to pick up the cards even as the number available gets up to 8 to 10.